Where History Rises—and So Does the Dough
This bakery started in a real kitchen, with real ingredients and a whole lot of hustle. The recipes? They’ve been around since the 1920s, but they’re not stuck in the past. I still make everything the same way: by hand, with care, and absolutely no shortcuts.
Every pie, cookie, and loaf is handcrafted—no mystery ingredients, no factory fluff. Just the good stuff, baked like my family always did: with love, butter, and a healthy respect for carbs.
Good food should feel like a celebration. Whether you’re chasing nostalgia or trying something brand new, I’m here to make sure your snack game is strong and your kitchen smells amazing.
This bakery isn’t just about treats—it’s about connection. For some folks, that means rediscovering the flavors they grew up with. For others, it’s tasting something homemade for the very first time. Either way, I’m here to make sure your kitchen smells like someone’s baking just for you.
This isn’t just a bakery. It’s a flavor-forward time machine, a carb-powered comfort zone, and a reminder that real baking still matters.
What you came for
Scratch‑made favorites, no mystery ingredients
Pick-Up & Delivery Options
​
Ready to roll? Place your order online for pick-up or delivery—easy peasy. Just Click on the Category below to see the goods!
​
Heads up: We need at least 24 hours to whip up your goodies. If you're in a rush or planning a big bash, reach out! We’ll do our best to make magic happen.
​
Pick-Up Location: Scroll down for the details.
Muffin Compares to These
Classic Comfort. Loud Flavor. Zero Apologies
Specialty Items
From Crumb to Crave
A Note on Ingredients & Allergens
At Amanda’s Old-Fashioned Bakery, we believe that using real, high-quality ingredients makes a difference—not just in taste, but in how people feel. We choose products that are simple, honest, and as close to the original recipes as possible. From pure vanilla to farm-fresh eggs and butter made with just cream and salt, our goal is to bring comfort and care into every bite.
​
That said, we are not an allergen-friendly bakery.
We use ingredients like dairy, wheat, and occasionally nuts. While we make every effort to avoid cross-contamination—especially with items like nuts, which are only used in select recipes and kept separate from daily baking—we cannot guarantee a completely allergen-free environment. Baking is hands-on, and sometimes messy, and we want everyone to stay safe.
​
Please know that the ingredients we showcase are examples of what we use most often. Occasionally, we may substitute based on availability, but we always aim to stay true to the spirit and flavor of our family’s original recipes.
If you have questions or concerns about specific ingredients, we encourage you to reach out before placing an order. Your safety matters, and we’re here to help.
Pick up Address
2729 E Moody Blvd #302
Inside A Darkhorse Productions Office
Bunnell, FL 32110
Phone
407-929-3017
